Book Butchers · First Chapter Critique · $297

First Chapter Critique: Find the Biggest Problems Before Readers Do

Get professional feedback before readers tear your book apart in the reviews. Most readers give a book five pages. Send me your first 5,000 words and I’ll tell you exactly where you’re losing them, why, and what to change, before you pay for a full edit.

  • 5,000 wordsyour opening chapters, prologue or intro
  • Two kinds of notescomments in your file + a written editorial letter
  • Blurb & keywordswho the book is for, and how to sell it
  • 100% refundif the critique isn’t useful, for any reason
Secure checkout with PayPal (card or PayPal account). Right after you pay, you upload your pages. No calls, no scheduling.

The opening decides whether anyone reads the rest

Whether they got a free review copy or paid full price, most readers decide in the first few pages. If they don’t care about your main character, can’t tell what’s happening, or feel the story hasn’t started yet, they put the book down and they don’t come back. Agents read the same way, only faster.

That’s why there’s no point editing a whole manuscript if the first chapter is losing people. Fix the opening first. Most of what I’ll point out in your first few chapters you can apply to the rest of the book yourself, which makes any later edit cheaper and better.

What you get

Notes in your manuscript

I read your pages the way a reader and an editor would, and leave comments in the file where the story stalls, confuses, repeats, or quietly works. Not a proofread: the notes are about the story, the scenes and the writing, with suggestions for how to fix each problem.

An editorial letter

A written critique that pulls it all together: what’s working, the biggest problems in order of importance, and what to do next. It covers:

  • genre expectations
  • target audience
  • character sympathy
  • scene depth
  • catalyst or inciting incident
  • writing style & fluency
  • pacing and intrigue
  • conflict and suspense
  • fatal flaw or core lack
  • feedback on weak writing
  • publishing advice

Bestseller coaching, built in

Who is this book for, and will they enjoy it? Until you know that, you can’t tell if you’re missing the mark, and choosing keywords and categories is guesswork. I’ll name your audience and genre, rewrite your blurb, and give you keywords and three hooks you can test in your marketing.

Bonus: my book marketing course

Every critique client gets free access to the 21 Day Bestselling Author Platform ($297 on its own), so you can build readers while you revise. You keep it even if you ask for a refund.

What the notes look like

Example: notes on an opening we wrote for this page (not a client’s book)

Maren had always known the lighthouse was haunted. Everyone in Gullhaven knew.1 She woke at six, as she did every morning,2 and made her coffee, and looked out at the grey water, and thought about her mother, who had died three years ago in the spring3, and about the letter she had found in the attic last week, which she still had not opened.4

  • If everyone knows, it isn’t a hook, it’s background. What does Maren know that nobody else does?
  • Waking up is one of the most common openings editors see. Start where her normal day breaks, not where it begins.
  • Three pieces of backstory in one breath. Readers will wait for these if you give them a question to hold first.
  • This is your story! Why hasn’t she opened it? That reluctance is more interesting than the ghost. Move it up front.

How it works

  1. OrderPay $297 through PayPal’s secure checkout, with your PayPal account or a card.
  2. Send your pagesYou’ll land on a short form: upload up to 5,000 words (Word, PDF, RTF or text) and tell me a little about the book.
  3. Get your critiqueI’ll email to confirm your pages arrived and give you a date (usually about two weeks), then send back your marked-up file, the editorial letter and your blurb and keywords.

Editors reply within 1-2 weeks. Paid already but didn’t see the form? Upload your pages here, or email [email protected]. Projects are read in the order they arrive.

The three questions every writer is really asking

Is it done?

Not sure it’s good enough to publish or query yet? I can tell you exactly what shape it’s in and what you need to do next, so you can get unstuck.

Is it good?

That’s probably the wrong question. The writing matters less than you think it does, and it’s easy to waste time and effort on the wrong things. But I can tell you if it’s good enough for a certain audience, because I know the market.

What’s next?

I won’t promise a publishing deal, but I will give you simple instructions and help you set realistic goals, whether that’s another draft, an editor, an agent query or a launch.

Why start here

Friends & beta readersFull developmental editFirst Chapter Critique
CostFree or cheapReedsy puts a 60,000-word developmental edit around $2,160$297
What you learnWhether they liked it (usually yes, to be kind)Everything, once the whole book is doneWhat’s losing readers in the part that matters most, and how to fix it
WhenAny timeAfter the draft is finishedNow, even mid-draft

What writers say

“I can’t thank you enough for taking the time to do a developmental edit on this. It was above and beyond and is greatly appreciated. It was exactly the guidance I needed to hear, and I would have waited three weeks for that, let alone a few days. Your insights will go a long way towards making this the best novel it can be.”Mikael Carlson, thriller author
“Finally, someone with the skills for analyzing a novice writer. Before meeting Derek Murphy, the “agents” I met in the publishing industry did nothing but side-step my requests for evaluation. It is now evident to me that the rubric which measures whether your book is sell-able or dead in the water, is literary experience. Your analysis combined honest evaluation with the goal being to produce a better book. I love the straightforward way you addressed my writing. I believe, this type of fed-back is essential to ANYONE who is writing. Your insight has proved invaluable.”Dr. George A. Munger, PhD
“This is EXACTLY the kind of feedback I was hoping for. Most appreciated. I have been continuing to tweak the story, but your feedback has really given me things I can sink my teeth into!”P. J. Viscio, horror author
“Thank you so much for this. I got the edits and I’m really happy with the extensive notes you made. It really does help. I think I’m going to do a major re-write […] Your input was so super helpful.”Marc, YA fantasy
“First of all, I would like to say that your editing on the intro, epilogue and first chapter is impressive! Finally, I was thinking that I am lucky to have found you. You are the best coach I could have!”Panagiotis Bampalis, health & fitness
“They live up to their name! Book Butchers hacked away at some loose points in my story. They aren’t afraid to tell you when something isn’t working, and that’s exactly what you want! Thanks to their revisions and story-related comments, I have a much better chance of getting my foot in the door with a publisher.”Matt Terrill
“Your suggestions have been wonderful! There was a lot of input you provided that I had not even considered, and will definitely help overall! Looking forward to going through the remainder of your suggestions tomorrow! Thank you again for your time!”Jacky, personal memoir

Who reads your pages

Derek Murphy, founder of Book Butchers

This critique is done personally by Derek Murphy, the founder of Book Butchers. I have a PhD in Literature, I’m a USA Today bestselling author, and I’ve written more than 5,000 critiques. (CNN featured me for renting castles.)

You might want an editor who’s an enthusiastic cheerleader, and I get that. What’s a grumpy recluse like me got to offer? Well, I’m pretty good at books. Unlike editors who just clean up your sentences, I’ll spot the structural problems and suggest creative fixes that make the story stronger. It’s a lot of honest feedback. It may not all be pleasant. It will be useful.

Trust and safety

  • Your pages go to me. Not to a pool of freelancers, not to a marketplace.
  • Your book stays yours. I never share, publish or reuse your writing, and it is never used to train AI.
  • No AI is writing your critique. The notes and the letter are my judgment. If you want no AI tools anywhere near your pages (not even a spellcheck), tick the box on the form and I’ll honor it.
  • Safe payment. Checkout runs on PayPal; we never see your card details.
  • 100% money-back guarantee. If you’re not happy with the critique for any reason, I’ll refund you in full, and you keep the marketing course. See our payments and refund policy.

Questions

What if my book isn’t finished yet?

That’s fine. A first chapter critique is a great place to start, because I can help you sort out the story structure so you can keep writing without getting stuck. Order now and send your pages whenever you’re ready.

Do I get a call?

No, and that’s on purpose. Everything happens by email: you send your pages, I send back detailed written notes you can keep and reread. If something in the notes isn’t clear, reply and ask.

How long does it take?

Usually about two weeks from the day your pages arrive. I’ll email you to confirm your pages came in and give you your date. Projects are read in the order they come in.

Can I send more than 5,000 words?

The critique covers your first 5,000 words, which is usually two or three chapters (or a prologue plus chapter one). If you want feedback on the whole book, say so in the form and I’ll tell you about the full manuscript critique.

Do you critique nonfiction?

Yes. For nonfiction I focus on the promise of the book, who it’s for, the structure of the opening chapters and whether the voice earns the reader’s trust.

How is this different from a beta reader?

A beta reader tells you what they liked and didn’t like. A critique tells you why something isn’t working and how to fix it. It’s the difference between “this part was confusing” and “your inciting incident is buried on page twelve, and here’s how to bring it forward.”

Is this editing or proofreading?

Neither, really. Proofreading fixes typos. Copy editing and line editing smooth sentences. This is the high-value part: honest feedback on the story itself, so you can make it better. I’ll still point out weak or repetitive writing when I see it.

Do you use AI?

Not to write your critique. I read every page and write every note myself. Like most editors I use ordinary software in my process, and if you’d rather nothing automated touched your pages, tick the box on the form. Your pages are never used to train AI. Worried about how your own writing reads? See do book editors use AI?

Can I get a refund?

Sure. Few editors offer a money-back guarantee because they can’t get their time back. If you’re not happy with the critique for any reason, I’ll refund you 100%.

Can I pay another way, or in installments?

PayPal checkout takes cards. If you’d rather pay through my course school, with an installment option, use the Teachable checkout; it’s the same critique.

Find out what your first chapter is really doing

The cheapest time to fix an opening is before you query an agent, pay for a full edit or launch. After that, the readers do the critiquing. 5,000 words. Notes in your file, an editorial letter, your blurb and keywords. $297, fully refundable.

Not ready to pay for feedback? Start with the free self-editing course.